Ming the Mechanic:
Software and distorted thinking

The NewsLog of Flemming Funch
 Software and distorted thinking2004-04-05 08:00
6 comments
picture by Flemming Funch

Peter Coffee has a nice article in eWeek, "Spreadsheets: 25 Years in a Cell", about how our use of certain software tools shape our behavior, and how different tools set us up for different assumptions and different fallacies and different ways of wasting our time.

Some companies have forbidden Powerpoint presentations in meetings. Because often people use a considerable amount of time at making their presentation look really impressive with graphical effects, but the time is often not very productive. It takes them 10 times as long to say the same thing, and it might just make it less clear what they're actually saying. A simple set of bulletpoints is often more clear.

And then there are spreadsheets:
"There are two ways that spreadsheets, as we know them, distort our thinking and lead to bad decisions. The first distortion is the use of point values and simple arithmetic instead of probability distributions and statistical measures. So far as I know, there's no off-the-shelf spreadsheet product—certainly none in common use—that provides for input of numbers as uncertain quantities, even though almost all of our decisions rest on forecasts or on speculations.

There are add-on products that incorporate uncertainty into spreadsheets, and many of them are quite good. Products of this kind that I've favorably reviewed over the years include DecisionTools Pro from Palisade and Crystal Ball Professional and CB Predictor from Decisioneering. It's not too hard to appreciate the difference between products that incorporate uncertainty and those that don't: On the one hand, you've got, "We predict a $1 million profit in the first year"; on the other, "The expected Year 1 profit is $1 million, but there's a 30 percent chance of losses for the first two years." These different statements will lead to quite different discussions."
We assume that because we can put some numbers in a spreadsheet that they somehow become more real and certain. And since the spreadsheet programs typically have no good way of representing the actual uncertainty, we skip over the subject. And it isn't enough that our tool allows us to represent several different alternative scenarios:
"The subjects whose tools invited them to imagine alternative scenarios believed they were doing a better job—even though statistical measures of their results showed no improvement in the actual quality of the forecasts. Those subjects did, however, take longer to perform the task. Isn't that the worst nightmare of those who must justify IT's return on investment—spending extra money on a more time-consuming product that yields absolutely no measurable improvement?"
It is a bit of an embarrassing secret that many of our computerized tools simply allow us to waste more time on making it look like we know what we're talking about, covering up the fact that we really don't.

We can get better tools, of course. Tools that better represent uncertainties and that show our assumptions more clearly. That's certainly an avenue to pursue. But we also need to develop our own built-in bullshit detectors, so that we can stay more conscious of the assumptions and fallacies inherent in what we're looking at, no matter how pretty and scientific it looks.


[< Back] [Ming the Mechanic]

Category:  

6 comments

5 Apr 2004 @ 20:33 by maxtobin : Now that is an idea
Where can I get the 'Bullshit detecting' software Ming, really could do with some for the next phase of the journey I feel. At present we just have to rely upon instinct and discernment I guess. (I guess that is one of the motivations for the expert web initiative, a bit like linkedin but with a more communal referencing of individual qualities!!)  


22 Aug 2016 @ 06:44 by National drink of Pakistan @39.36.247.24 : Malik
All the traloom.  


18 Sep 2016 @ 10:13 by poker online betting @202.58.97.174 : me cannot stop
you made a very inspiring , thanks for the information , really impressive  


5 Oct 2016 @ 11:38 by snapchat for pc @117.207.103.144 : tfd
hi http://www.mobogenieforpcc.com
good http://www.snapchatforpcdownload.com
post http://www.ucbrowserforpcc.com
snapchat windows http://www.snapchatforpcdownload.com/2016/06/snapchat-pc-free-download-windows-xp788-110/
snapchat for linux http://www.snapchatforpcdownload.com/2016/06/snapchat-for-linux-free-download/
snapchatdownload http://www.snapchatforpcdownload.com/2016/06/snapchat-download/
snapchat app http://www.snapchatforpcdownload.com/2016/06/snapchat-app-free-download/
mac http://www.snapchatforpcdownload.com/2016/06/snapchat-for-mac-pc-free-download/
ios http://www.snapchatforpcdownload.com/2016/06/snapchat-app-for-ios-free-download/
android http://www.snapchatforpcdownload.com/2016/06/snapchat-for-android-free-download/
windows http://www.mobogenieforpcc.com/2016/06/mobogenie-for-pc-windows-xp788-110-html/
app http://www.mobogenieforpcc.com/2016/06/mobogenie-app-free-download/
ios http://www.mobogenieforpcc.com/2016/06/mobogenie-for-ios-free-download/
android http://www.mobogenieforpcc.com/2016/06/mobogenie-for-android-free-download/
windows http://www.ucbrowserforpcc.com/2016/06/uc-browser-for-pc-free-download-windows-xp-7-8-10/
ios http://www.ucbrowserforpcc.com/2016/06/uc-browser-for-ios-free-download/
mac http://www.ucbrowserforpcc.com/2016/06/uc-browser-for-mac-pc-free-download/
android phone http://www.ucbrowserforpcc.com/2015/12/uc-browser-apk-for-android-phone-free-download/
windows phone http://www.ucbrowserforpcc.com/2015/12/uc-browser-for-windows-phone-free-download/  



5 Oct 2016 @ 12:06 by xender for pc @117.207.103.144 : xender
http://www.xenderforpcapp.com  


13 Nov 2016 @ 08:44 by agen domino terpercaya @103.12.162.198 : fantastic
http://agendomino.tk
ok
http://judidominokiukiu.tk
ok
http://judidominokiukiu.ml
ok
http://judidominokiukiu.ga
ok
http://judidominokiukiu.cf
ok
http://judidominokiukiu.gq
ok
http://qiuqiuonlineuangasli.tk
ok
http://qiuqiuonlineuangasli.ml
ok
http://qiuqiuonlineuangasli.ga
ok
http://qiuqiuonlineuangasli.cf
ok
http://qiuqiuonlineuangasli.gq
ok
http://judionlinedominoqq.tk
ok
http://judionlinedominoqq.ml
ok
http://judionlinedominoqq.ga
ok
http://judionlinedominoqq.cf
ok
http://judionlinedominoqq.gq
ok
http://situsjudiqqonlineterpercaya.tk
ok
http://situsjudiqqonlineterpercaya.ml
ok
http://situsjudiqqonlineterpercaya.ga
ok
http://situsjudiqqonlineterpercaya.cf
ok
http://situsjudiqqonlineterpercaya.gq  



Your Name:
Your URL: (or email)
Subject:       
Comment:
For verification, please type the word you see on the left:


Other stories in
2007-12-26 21:19: LeWeb3
2007-07-04 23:14: Orbo free energy
2007-06-28 22:03: Wide-angle Immersive Stereoscope
2007-06-24 16:51: Spy box
2007-06-14 01:00: Photosynth
2007-04-25 14:01: Open source hardware
2007-03-22 16:33: The Air Car
2007-03-09 23:44: Web 2.0
2007-02-07 16:09: Talkr
2007-01-12 00:15: Open Source Desktop Fabricator



[< Back] [Ming the Mechanic] [PermaLink]? 


Link to this article as: http://ming.tv/flemming2.php/__show_article/_a000010-001183.htm
Main Page: ming.tv