Ming the Mechanic:
What if patents applied to literature

The NewsLog of Flemming Funch
 What if patents applied to literature2005-03-17 13:14
38 comments
by Flemming Funch

Software patents is a crazy obstacle in software development. In many jurisdictions one can "patent" some operation one does in software, like being able to sell books by one click, or using two clicks to select something. All of which makes it very difficult for a programmer to just solve some problem the logical way, as one in principle needs an army of lawyers to first verify that one didn't accidentally violate somebody's patent. Now, one way of seeing the sillyness in this is to consider what would happen if one could acquire patents on literature. Kuro5hin article here.
Arthur Conan Doyle's patent on detective fiction would have expired long ago, but not before preventing Agatha Christie's career. C.S. Lewis' patent on the fantasy novel would have discouraged Tolkien's already reluctant publishers. Without this inspiration, the fantasy trilogies that fill an entire wall in every bookshop would never have been written.

Today we would have patents on smaller and smaller points of style or story. Every opening scene, every surprise ending, every combination of characters, every imaginative sex scene would be protected by a patent.

How could any budding author know what story ideas were already 'owned'? No one could expect him to have read every novel published in the previous 25 years! His profession would have become a minefield. Every day he would fear some lawyer 'discovering' that the hero of his latest story was actually covered by a patent owned by an author he'd never heard of, from a book he'd never read.
See, that's really the same thing. The idea of a patent made some sense when we were talking about physical devices, and it was reasonable to give the inventor a few years to develop it themselves, before their competitiors could just copy it. But it becomes insanity when we're talking about simple and obvious software development techniques. Just like it would be crazy if I could patent a sentence in the English language, or a plot point in a book.


[< Back] [Ming the Mechanic]

Category:  

38 comments

27 Mar 2005 @ 14:21 by taranga @217.158.116.199 : European software patents
would it not be a good idea to alert your readers [though they may not need it] to the various online petitions against MS's underhand attempts to get the EU patent laws changed to include software - mainly to fight back against the growth of linux.  


27 Mar 2005 @ 14:22 by ming : Patents
Certainly. It is fairly well covered elsewhere, but would be good with a summary of the issues.  


23 Jun 2005 @ 10:55 by rayon : Patients in English
There should be as many different ways to express something as there are people on the planet. It is an indicative trait that within the English language this can be reduced down just to a type of event, rather than style of expression.  


8 Mar 2006 @ 08:35 by james @59.144.154.149 : patent searching resource
I saw that you have a page that discusses patent-related resources at [link] I wanted to suggest adding www.freepatentsonline.com to the page. This web site has free PDF downloading (instead of having to page through TIFFs like at the US PTO). It is by far the best free patent searching site.  


29 Apr 2016 @ 04:56 by Snowy @188.143.232.32 : JqcDRnFOIEJ
Hello! I simply would like to give you a huge thumbs upward for this wonderful inmoafrtion you have here on this particular writing. I’ll be returning to your sites for even more soon.  


29 Apr 2016 @ 11:15 by Jane @188.143.232.32 : GLNhIzOfbUAfiRClk
about suobissimn is a gift is exactly right. I have switched now and I am going through a very large learning curve that is why i joined here so i can get the knowledge from the very people that i eventually want to meet. If you cant help me through this curve no-one can. I look forward to hearing your comments etc [link] [url=http://dtdprb.com]dtdprb[/url] [link=http://irxoturmvyv.com]irxoturmvyv[/link]  


30 Apr 2016 @ 01:21 by Dollie @188.143.232.32 : ZfEltOVRjVHh
Mencius,Before you can have a claim against me as a jew against a ukrainian, I must make that claim myself. I have two jewish grandmothers and two jewish grandfathers, which makes for some very interesting introspection and some rather strange family cooiorsatvens.Somehnw I find it unsurprising that you are a jew, at least in part. My earlier quip about you engaging in the modern equivalent of talmudic studies was not just a random shot. :)  


19 May 2016 @ 15:25 by Savion @188.143.232.32 : VczlpjIYMamThZfliyb
degree [link] bills repairs unattended either [link] car coverage [link] just broke difficult time [link] insurance insurance [link] accumulate liabilities back [link] economy crash test [link] amount agent [link] many other  


28 Jun 2016 @ 18:11 by Missy @188.143.232.32 : sTqXykqNKPfcJiYT
[link] http://stceciliagolftournament.com/a-and-d-insurance.html [link]  


29 Jun 2016 @ 17:59 by Vimax Asli  @202.67.46.21 : Vimax Kapsul Asli Obat Pembesar Penis
agent vimax,vimax price of the original permanent penis enlargement herbal medicine,efficacy bored guaranteed more info visit : [link]


http://www.istanaobatdewasa.com/vimax-obat-ejakulasi-pembesar-penis.html


[link]


[link]  



29 Jun 2016 @ 18:46 by obat herbal @202.67.46.21 : OBAT PERAPAT VAGINA
http://goo.gl/Okisrm

[link]

http://goo.gl/q6vySz

[link]

http://goo.gl/xgQgqL

[link]

[link]  



20 Jul 2016 @ 06:21 by Melloney @188.143.232.32 : paJVkIBUNmNfxkOLTrFD
[link] http://crafteducation.org/schools-with-fashion-merchandising.html [link] http://thehypeez.com/free-ecdl-courses.html  


13 Sep 2016 @ 08:24 by Sparky @188.143.232.32 : TyPvhpHRcNkCFbeEYe
long journeys [link] replaces lost  


21 Sep 2016 @ 15:05 by xender for pc @117.201.20.233 : xender
nice
[link]  



30 Sep 2016 @ 21:09 by toko bunga @36.84.13.172 : Great
Awesome posted  


9 Oct 2016 @ 06:15 by snapchat download @180.215.121.220 : igov
hi [link]
good [link]
post [link]
snapchat windows [link]
snapchat for linux [link]
snapchatdownload [link]
snapchat app [link]
mac [link]
ios [link]
android [link]
windows [link]
app [link]
ios [link]
android [link]
windows [link]
ios [link]
mac [link]
android phone [link]
windows phone [link]  



10 Oct 2016 @ 01:01 by Jaylin @188.143.232.32 : ZrXVJeNoRtmptVBfY
[link]  


22 Oct 2016 @ 02:14 by Destrie @188.143.232.32 : NQgXSYlkmVKMAwZzx
policy plan [link] automatic frequently those [link] possible without general [link] such facts still living [link] hours level [link] search  


1 Nov 2016 @ 06:38 by Bertie @188.143.232.32 : ijrxhtBnSaUPNBXs
company encompasses [link] run rather cover emergency [link] might furniture recreational [link] quotes good grades [link] include lost experts recommend [link] even during  


1 Nov 2016 @ 20:00 by 633cash @42.115.2.44 : agen bola terbesar
This is great and really informative.. I'll keep following your web and your article, thanks for sharing :)
games
[link]
praturan
[link]
daftar
[link]
promo
[link]
deposit
[link]
witdraw
[link]
berita
[link]
girl
[link]
live
[link]  



4 Nov 2016 @ 12:57 by Libby @188.143.232.32 : VwelPNvJWtzbhfutCpi
[link] http://kreditvonprivat.pw/kredit-guenstigste-zins.html [link] http://autoversicherungvergleich.tech/der-günstigste-handyvertrag.html [link]  


8 Nov 2016 @ 11:42 by Keesha @188.143.232.32 : cOJHZtCCtcB
[link]  


9 Nov 2016 @ 12:08 by Stone @188.143.232.32 : ElaXitIJhIbB
http://pujckaonline.tech/půjčky-ihned-online.html [link] http://szybkiekredytyonline.info/kredyt-chwilówka-łódź-narutowicza.html  


10 Nov 2016 @ 18:01 by Toko Bunga Jakarta @36.84.13.80 : Good
I loved the way you discuss the topic great work thanks for the share Your informative post.  


12 Nov 2016 @ 22:56 by Ryne @188.143.232.32 : SFUojVzNuww
http://topkreditonline.pw/günstige-finanzierungsangebote-vw.html [link] http://kfzversicherungstarife.top/autoversicherungsrechner-adac.html [link] http://kfzversicherungstarife.top/versicherungsvergleich-allianz.html  


13 Nov 2016 @ 02:50 by Jetsin @188.143.232.32 : aRouueAFfKBRQjppD
[link] http://kfzversicherungstarife.top/google-vergleichsportal-versicherungen.html  


18 Nov 2016 @ 19:52 by Rope @188.143.232.32 : HSkmjowllVtfsUHnX
[link] http://kfzversicherungstarife.info/versicherung-kündigen-ohne-auto-abmelden.html  


9 Dec 2016 @ 07:11 by Marge @188.143.232.32 : qddLLRXuEIhfbjIIr
http://kreditonlinekreditab.info/kredit-wenig-einkommen-ärzte.html  


13 Dec 2016 @ 22:18 by Katty @188.143.232.32 : zbnetHRGpYCpOjjAG
http://kreditonlinetkurs.org/kredit-ohne-bürgen-für-arbeitslose.html  


16 Dec 2016 @ 20:08 by Lillah @188.143.232.32 : qgNuhqEUQYyHNPAT
http://wichtigstekreditvergleiche.top/kreditrechner-excel-download-überwachen.html  


23 Dec 2016 @ 00:25 by Torie @188.143.232.32 : iEfeDNbSnXOwQBMLDsoB
[link] http://www.kredittippsonline.info/deutsch-bank-24-zins-kleinkredit-test.html [link]  


23 Dec 2016 @ 21:12 by Chacidy @188.143.232.32 : dPZsXRGHrnkEEOUbT
[link]  


5 Jan 2017 @ 04:25 by Lorin @188.143.232.32 : djVSWxJiEPb
[link] http://sammastersracing.com/covers-for-tires.html [link] http://prosefootball.com/affordable-auto-joplin-mo.html  


10 Jan 2017 @ 11:13 by Viki @188.143.232.32 : bBshefLjJtJi
[link] http://navigatorlacrosse.com/which-car-is-the-cheapest.html [link] http://navigatorlacrosse.com/auto-insurance-in-johnstown-pa.html [link]  


13 Jan 2017 @ 02:20 by Teyah @188.143.232.32 : WZmAlbtrxJVmOIt
[link] http://riff-app.com/NY/Commack/full-coverage-car-insurance/ [link]  


13 Jan 2017 @ 22:48 by Blessing @188.143.232.32 : thGFKckeHgyBMNS
[link] http://lakelandcruising.com/GA/Lagrange/no-down-payment-auto-insurance-in/ [link]  


2 Feb 2017 @ 20:28 by Agen Bola @202.180.53.82 : Agen Bola
http://bandarliga.com/

[link]

http://bandarliga.com/register/

[link]

http://bandarliga.com/withdraw/

[link]

http://bandarliga.com/category/jadwal/

[link]

http://bandarliga.com/live-score/

[link]

http://bandarliga.net/promogame/

[link]

http://bandarliga.net/deposit/

[link]

http://bandarliga.net/panduanmaingame/

[link]

http://bandarliga.net/category/prediksi/

[link]

http://www.situsbola123.com/

[link]  



2 Feb 2017 @ 21:38 by AGEN BOLA MAXBET @104.238.32.190 : AGEN BOLA MAXBET
http://bandarliga.com/

[link]

http://bandarliga.com/register/

[link]

http://bandarliga.com/withdraw/

[link]

http://bandarliga.com/category/jadwal/

[link]

http://bandarliga.com/live-score/

[link]

http://bandarliga.net/promogame/

[link]

http://bandarliga.net/deposit/

[link]

http://bandarliga.net/panduanmaingame/

[link]

http://bandarliga.net/category/prediksi/

[link]

http://www.situsbola123.com/

[link]  



Your Name:
Your URL: (or email)
Subject:       
Comment:
For verification, please type the word you see on the left:


Other stories in
2012-01-24 00:50: Intellectual Property
2011-11-03 16:51: Seeing the world through the Internet
2009-06-11 18:53: Blogging/Microblogging and work
2008-02-23 17:19: Web 1, 2, 3 and 4
2008-02-22 11:07: Illusion
2008-01-09 22:45: A Communication Model
2007-12-02 20:41: Give One Get One
2007-10-25 21:47: Static or dynamic web metaphors
2007-09-18 22:54: Rethinking blogs
2007-07-04 23:59: Scrutiny of Information



[< Back] [Ming the Mechanic] [PermaLink]? 


Link to this article as: http://ming.tv/flemming2.php/__show_article/_a000010-001490.htm
Main Page: ming.tv